The sun went down while we were on the ferry, so we had to find our bed & breakfast in the dark... we knew it was on a farm - but when the sun rose the next morning the view was breathtaking (and they had a dozen new tiny lambs running around)! We found our delightful bed & breakfast run by a sweet old couple online, and I would highly recommend it (the bathroom was HUUUUUGE!). We also had massages on the island and had a Mexican feast on new year's eve!
On New Years day, we spent the entire day exploring every road on the island. We visited the lakes, parks, and drove all the way to the top and saw Canada!